.png){kind=logo}
10 signatures reached
To: Lindsey Anderson Beer and Sony Pictures
Recast Sydney Sweeney in the Sleepy Hollow Remake: Protect the Legacy of a Gothic Classic
We Want a Different Leading Lady for Sleepy Hollow
Sleepy Hollow is a beloved gothic story with a rich atmosphere, haunting beauty, and a legacy that deserves to be respected. The announcement of a remake should be an opportunity to bring something meaningful and creatively compelling to the screen.
However, the casting of Sydney Sweeney has left many potential viewers disappointed and questioning whether she is the right person to lead this project.
We are calling on the filmmakers behind Sleepy Hollow to reconsider this casting decision and give another actress the opportunity to bring this iconic gothic story to life.
Why We Are Speaking Out
Sydney Sweeney’s public image has increasingly become a source of controversy, particularly surrounding her advertising campaigns.
In 2025, her American Eagle “Great Jeans” campaign sparked widespread criticism over its use of the words “jeans” and “genes.” Critics questioned the campaign’s messaging and its potential associations with eugenics and narrow beauty standards.
More recently, her 2026 Novig sports betting advertisement, featuring provocative imagery and nudity, drew criticism from female athletes who argued that it sexualized women in sports.
These controversies have contributed to concerns about the public image she brings to major projects, particularly one being presented as a feminist film.
For many of us, the issue is not simply about disliking an actress. It is about whether the casting aligns with the themes, atmosphere, and artistic vision of a story as iconic as Sleepy Hollow.
What We Are Asking For
We are calling on the filmmakers and production team to:
Reconsider Sydney Sweeney’s casting in the Sleepy Hollow remake.
Consider actresses whose artistic presence and public image better align with the film’s gothic atmosphere and intended themes.
Take the concerns of potential viewers seriously when making creative decisions.
We Have a Choice as an Audience
Many of us have no intention of watching the remake if Sydney Sweeney remains in the leading role.
We believe Sleepy Hollow deserves a thoughtful adaptation that respects its gothic roots and brings a fresh, compelling perspective to the story.
Sign this petition if you believe the filmmakers should reconsider the casting and give another actress the opportunity to lead this gothic
Sleepy Hollow is a beloved gothic story with a rich atmosphere, haunting beauty, and a legacy that deserves to be respected. The announcement of a remake should be an opportunity to bring something meaningful and creatively compelling to the screen.
However, the casting of Sydney Sweeney has left many potential viewers disappointed and questioning whether she is the right person to lead this project.
We are calling on the filmmakers behind Sleepy Hollow to reconsider this casting decision and give another actress the opportunity to bring this iconic gothic story to life.
Why We Are Speaking Out
Sydney Sweeney’s public image has increasingly become a source of controversy, particularly surrounding her advertising campaigns.
In 2025, her American Eagle “Great Jeans” campaign sparked widespread criticism over its use of the words “jeans” and “genes.” Critics questioned the campaign’s messaging and its potential associations with eugenics and narrow beauty standards.
More recently, her 2026 Novig sports betting advertisement, featuring provocative imagery and nudity, drew criticism from female athletes who argued that it sexualized women in sports.
These controversies have contributed to concerns about the public image she brings to major projects, particularly one being presented as a feminist film.
For many of us, the issue is not simply about disliking an actress. It is about whether the casting aligns with the themes, atmosphere, and artistic vision of a story as iconic as Sleepy Hollow.
What We Are Asking For
We are calling on the filmmakers and production team to:
Reconsider Sydney Sweeney’s casting in the Sleepy Hollow remake.
Consider actresses whose artistic presence and public image better align with the film’s gothic atmosphere and intended themes.
Take the concerns of potential viewers seriously when making creative decisions.
We Have a Choice as an Audience
Many of us have no intention of watching the remake if Sydney Sweeney remains in the leading role.
We believe Sleepy Hollow deserves a thoughtful adaptation that respects its gothic roots and brings a fresh, compelling perspective to the story.
Sign this petition if you believe the filmmakers should reconsider the casting and give another actress the opportunity to lead this gothic
Why is this important?
This petition is about more than one actress. It is about giving fans a voice in the creative decisions behind a story they love. We want a leading lady who embodies the dark, mysterious, and captivating essence of Sleepy Hollow and who feels right for the world being created.
If you believe this gothic classic deserves a different leading lady, if you are disappointed by the casting, or if you simply want filmmakers to listen to the audiences who support their projects, please sign this petition.
If you believe this gothic classic deserves a different leading lady, if you are disappointed by the casting, or if you simply want filmmakers to listen to the audiences who support their projects, please sign this petition.