Skip to main content

To: Governor Maura Healey, Colonel Charles Silvanic, General Kenneth Wisbach, Pete Hegseth, Representative Stephen Lynch, and Senator Patrick O'Connor

"Let's Save Fourth Cliff Family Recreation Area in Scituate, MA"

Fourth Cliff Family Recreation Area in Scituate, MA, has been serving active duty and retired military personnel since 1952, one of the few locations for rest and recreation on the East Coast. Thousands of people, many retired to New England, count this as a lifesaver for their military career, a beautiful gem encircled by the Atlantic Ocean, and North and South Rivers. While patronizing area businesses during their stay, Fourth Cliff guests are a boon to the local economy. Atlantic storms in recent years have ravaged the cliff protecting its frontage, jeopardizing several historic landmarks, tent and RV sites, guest houses, and beach usage. PLEASE SHARE THIS POST (& A MEMORY OF 4TH CLIFF IF YOU HAVE ONE AS A REASON FOR SIGNING).

Why is this important?

Permanent corrective action to armor the cliff with a rip-rap system has been in place since April 5, 2013 – Project # GXUN 13-0016 – and even has been funded several times, with that money then put to other uses. Local, state, and federal agencies are all aware of the problem and detailed studies have been completed with multiple state and local agencies participating. But year after year this project, important to thousands of military and federal personnel, drops out of the funding formula despite this long-standing plan and remedy. 

Meanwhile prices rise and the damage continues, making the immediate cliff a danger, though not one person has been injured in all this time. The site is currently under the ownership of Hanscom Air Force Base’s 66th Air Base Group, with many of its neighbors to the south on Humarock Beach having adequately armored their properties on their own dollar. The people who have signed this petition (with family and friends who know of and have enjoyed Fourth Cliff) urge these lawmakers to take action and see that Project GXUN 13-0016 gets funded this year, saving Fourth Cliff for posterity as an R&R gem. It is also sanctuary to three endangered species of birds. 

As a 100% disabled veteran with a Purple Heart and two Bronze Star metals from combat in Vietnam, Fourth Cliff has been a great blessing to my wife and I for 45 years, from tenting to renting guest houses, to holding our daughter’s wedding in the Pavilion, to beachcombing, swimming, and fishing. My three grown children and grandchildren enjoy and love Fourth Cliff. This is our favorite location in all of New England, no, in the United States, a real gem. Contemplating a future without it is almost too hard to imagine. 

The announcement of its closure late this year for safety reasons (though no one has been injured there in its history), drove me to post this petition and urge our lawmakers to “Save Fourth Cliff!” It is not too late. Find a way to fund this 2013 project now, and provide the resources needed to upgrade an important historical site and campground for thousands of military members and residents who are an important boon to the local economy.

Take another look at my pictures here: If your front yard looked like this, what do you think the town you lived in would do? You know the answer to this question. So what about the US Air Force leaving its front yard like this? Who will hold it accountable? It must be our lawmakers, local, state, and federal! Do your job as leaders to make 4th Cliff safe for the thousands of military and government people who seek R&R there!

How it will be delivered

Through military and VA Facebook pages ... Those who have visited Fourth Cliff are encouraged to use this link to share their experience on Craig Naylor's "Help Us Save 4th Cliff -- Humarock" on Military Famcamps Facebook page:
https://www.facebook.com/groups/2332669477176557/posts/2513773049066198/?comment_id=2515486542228182&reply_comment_id=2515496535560516&notif_id=1786017924155282&notif_t=group_comment_mention

Links

Updates

2026-10-29 09:14:12 -0400

To my "Save 4th Cliff" Friends, retired Lt. Col. Thomas Maeder, one of our petition signers, sent a letter to key Air Force leaders asking for a FIX & FUNDING folllow-through for the Cliff. It is well written, articulate, full of the history and importance of our place, and very respectfully mailed out. I have posted a copy on Craig Nailer's Facebook site referenced here, well worth a read, and Tom has given us an OK to use it and send it out to anyone we think could help us. Check it out. Here is the link: https://www.facebook.com/groups/2332669477176557/posts/2513773049066198/?comment_id=2515486542228182&reply_comment_id=2515496535560516&notif_id=1786017924155282&notif_t=group_comment_mention

2026-10-21 13:36:33 -0400

Dear Friends, we have made a real difference in getting Hanscom AFB to keep 4th Cliff open, a phase 1 victory. I suggest Phase 2, sending a message to key AF personnel & our two MA Senators: Dear…I signed the “Let’s Save Fourth Cliff Family Rec Area” petition, and am pleased to say Hanscom AFB is not closing it for now. I now have a BIG ASK- When will permanent corrective action to armor the cliff (Project # GXUN 13-0016) be reinstated and how will it be funded and completed? I look forward to getting answers and permanently “Saving 4th Cliff” for present and future active duty and retired military. Send to Colonel Charles Silvanic (Contact Form on Hanscom website), General Kenneth Wisbach (Contact Form https://www.aF.mil/ContacT-Us/), and General Dan Caine (Mail Joint Staff Public Affairs, 9999 Joint Staff Pentagon, Room 2D932, Washington, DC 20318). Thanks, we have made a difference, but need to MoveOn to Phase 2, get the plan reinstated and funded.

2026-10-18 08:37:08 -0400

Yes, Fourth Cliff is still open per decision of the current Commander at Hanscom AFB Colonel Charles Silvanic, which is truly good news. I have to believe that our efforts to lobby with the above six leaders (and others) has has an impact and maybe the reason for this result. I plan to talk to Dale Minnis, the 4th Cliff director, this week to get his advice on how to move forward. My sense is that unless we can convince decision-makers to reinstate the plan to repair the cliff (and fund it), we will see a closure decison in the future, because erosion and damage to the cliff will surely not cease under the current conditions. My hunch is that we should push local, state, and federal leaders to put that repair plan back into effect and set a priority to fund it ASAP. More on it this week.

2026-10-01 19:14:10 -0400

News today that one of our signers wrote 5 letters on saving Fourth Cliff and got a response today from Senator Elizabeth Warren's office, with news that the Senator has now heard from others about the closing, so now we have personal responses from two MA Senators. May that translate into action on our behalf! Also mention of a BBQ at Fourth Cliff, which would be a very good followup to our efforts here but I do not have the band width to plan it- if someone in our ranks can plan it I will contribute financially, invite my contacts in Senator Markey's office, and attend. We still have some good weather to work with. Any of you out there that could take that on, even team up to do it? Sunday probably the best bet.

2026-09-30 06:39:20 -0400

Hello All, so here is a response from the Director of Fourth Cliff after that "wicked nor'easter," a positive report after I inquired:

Hello Noel,
I got side tracked... we made it thru another storm... intact... Fourth Cliff survived another... storm...26 [years]... of my time here plus 24 years of Roger [former director]... plus all the years as far back as 1898... how many years was that??? somewhere around 128 years... and Fourth Cliff is still here!!~??
Dale Minnis

2026-09-26 22:15:46 -0400

Today I mailed nine leaders our Petition with 1000+ signatures, pictures of the cliff, and a cover letter, by certified mail. Of the $103.50 donations you all contributed, I have $4 left over. Here is a list of who received it: Colonel Charles Silvanic (Hanscom AFB), Dr. Troy Meink (Sect of the AF), Maura Healey (MA Gov), General Ken Wilsbach (AF Chief of Staff), Pete Hegseth (US Sec of Defense), Ed Markey (MA Senator), Elizabeth Warren (MA Senator), Patrick O'Connor (MA Senator for Situate), and Stephen Lynch (MA House of Reps). I will post to their online pages that the envelope is coming, you all can do the same, all but two have online communication. I will check in with Dale on TU about how Fourth Cliff fared in this fierce storm, National Weather service calling it a "wicked Nor'easter!" Take care, friends, lets keep trying to Save Fourth Cliff.

2026-09-25 09:49:23 -0400

Stock message to use: Dear... , Fourth Cliff Family Recreation Area in Scituate, MA, has been serving active-duty and retired military personnel since 1952, making it perfect for R&R. Thousands consider it a lifesaver, a gem encircled by the Atlantic Ocean and North and South Rivers. 4th Cliff is also a boon to the local economy. Storms have ravaged the cliff protecting its frontage, jeopardizing this historic landmark. Permanent corrective action to armor the cliff with a riprap system, Project # GXUN 13-0016, was proposed April 5, 2013. Although it was funded several times, the money was reallocated. The cliff is now a danger, but no one has been injured to date. The site is owned by Hanscom Air Force Base, with plans to study and probably close the site. Neighbors to the south have armored their properties with private funding. I urge you to act immediately to ensure this project gets funded, saving Fourth Cliff for generations of service members.

2026-09-23 20:06:57 -0400

Many of you are asking me how you can help. The decision-makers above, most of them, have online forms you can post up to 1000 characters about saving Fourth Cliff. You can do the same with Senators Warren and Markey. Another key official is the Sect of the Air Force but you would have to mail him: The Honorable Dr. Troy E. Meink, Secretary of the Air Force,
1670 Air Force Pentagon, Washington, DC 20330-1670; Hegseth is only reachable by mail. If you want to message the President or VP Vance, they have online forms easy to post to. My thoughts and prayers are out for Dale and Fourth Cliff this weekend with a powerful Nor'easter is headed in from SA to M. This is the kind of storm that takes feet off the cliff and precisely why we need the Air Force to fix it per its plan. Donations to my mailing of our Petition and signatures are still welcome, my PayPal my email [email protected]. I also have a Venmo address Noel-Sherry-2.

2026-09-20 13:59:17 -0400

Some good news, we are having an impact, Senator Markey involved now, Commander @ Hanscom AFB will keep 4th Cliff open pending study, see quote below from what one of our signers, John Freedman, received. But need to keep pressure on to get the cliff fixed. Mailing out our signatures & petition this week, received $60 donations so far from youall to help defray costs, thanks, my PayPal is [email protected], Venmo Noel-Sherry-2, money received above what's needed will be donated to 4th Cliff or MoveOn.org.
Quote: "Reservations for the Fourth Cliff Recreation Area were temporarily paused but have been reopened. The Dept of the Air Force will continue to assess the sustainability of the Fourth Cliff Recreation Area. Any final decisions regarding an Air Force program or activity are made at the Headquarters Air Force level."
Communication with the Air Force @ the Pentagon & Hanscom AFB should continue! We are making an impact.

2026-09-16 11:21:41 -0400

1,000 signatures reached

2026-09-11 15:09:36 -0400

Dear supporters of Fourth Cliff Family Recreation Area, I got my first real bite today, with a key official in Senator Markey's office in Boston taking interest and reaching out to Hanscom AFB for comment and response. I hope to have her and maybe an investigative reporter meet me at the gate in Scituate for a tour of this absolute gem even with the damage, to have them see for themselves how the US Air Force has left its front yard facing the ocean. Your personal message to Colonel Charles Silvanic (Hanscom AFB) or the Secretary of the Air Force (Dr. Troy E. Meink) might make a difference at this point. Keep your hope up and get the word out. A little action can leverage a lot. I also believe in the power of prayer!

2026-09-09 01:48:05 -0400

Hello Signers of our "Save Fourth Cliff Family Recreation Area" Petition, here is one thing you could do which will only take a few minutes, contact the major newspaper in your area of New England (if a NE resident) and post a request to their tip line to do a story on the closing of 4th Cliff by the Air Force & Our attempt to save it, giving them a link to this Petition to get all the info they need to do the story. So here are the major news sources here in New England you could contact: Boston Globe or Springfield Republican (MA), Concord Monitor (NH), Portland Press Herald (ME), Hartford Courant (CT), Providence Journal (RI). or Vermont Montpelior Bridge (VT). Thanks for signing and supporting this petition!

2026-09-07 01:41:37 -0400

i am currently in Denmark on a family visit, my spouse Ingelise being Danish, and watching our signature list grow. Will print it out and send to our six plus decision makers with a plea to save the Cliff, plus others, in hopes of reaching 1000 people on our list! Keep sharing it with your circle of friends and Facebook pages!

2026-08-29 14:00:40 -0400

Unfortunately I will not be able to plan a BBQ at Fourth Cliff. But the date of SA Sep 26th is open and the beach area is available for about $50, the Pavilion for a little over $100. I would certainly attend a noon to two BBQ, Dale the director is willing to be part of it, and I am sure a good group of 4th Cliff supporters would show up. I would be glad to make a contribution toward that event and food, but just cannot plan it out.

2026-08-25 06:52:27 -0400

I have been lobbying at least 10 local, state and federal decision makers who might impact this matter, and now that we have reached over 500 signatures and climbing, I will print out our list and mail it to the six leaders listed here (and selected others) this Friday. I will email all of you signers with one last request for you to lobby key leaders, but I am waiting to get a letter from Dale Minis, the Director of Fourth Cliff, written by an Air Force general offering strong support for keeping 4th Cliff open. I am contemplating a BBQ in late September at Fourth Cliff's Pavilion, a pep rally for Saving Fourth Cliff, but would need some donations toward the hamburgs, hot dogs, porato salad, drinks, etc. Have not scheduled that yet.