To: Susan McCartney (Mayor) and Members of the Zoning Board: Philip D. Neuer, Irv Schwarzbaum, William Michael Barbee, Laurence Cohen, Robin Miller, Brent D. Scott, Alice Weiss

Vote NO to Zoning Variances in West Orange

West Orange, New Jersey
To West Orange Authorities: Susan McCartney (Mayor of West Orange), Diana L. Chandler (Zoning Board Secretary), Geniece Gary-Adams (Director of Planning & Development/Zoning official)

To Members of the Zoning Board: Philip D. Neuer, Chairperson / Irv Schwarzbaum, Vice-Chairperson / William Michael Barbee / Laurence Cohen / Robin Miller / Brent D. Scott / Alice Weiss / Mark Sussman (Alt.) / Michael Dannemiller (Alt.) / Tal Ben-Zvi (Alt ) / Todd Dubovy (Alt.)

To Municipal Officials: Savo, Schalk, Corsini, Warner, Gillespie, O’Grodnick & Fisher PA, Board Attorneys / CME Associates, Consulting Planner / John J. Hess, PE, PP, Consulting Engineer / Zayibeth Carballo, Municipal Engineer
--- 

Dear Mayor, dear members of the Zoning Board, dear Municipal officials,

We, the undersigned residents of West Orange, demand that the Zoning Board DENY Application ZB-25-07 in its entirety. We strongly oppose the requested use variances and any accompanying site adjustments. We respectfully request:

  • Safeguard us from fire and safety hazards. Operating a heavy-duty automotive repair shop, routinely handling flammable liquids, fuel systems, and welding equipment, in close proximity to existing fueling stations raises legitimate fire and safety concerns for a corridor never planned or designed for this concentration of combustible-material handling.

  • Uphold our zoning ordinance and Master Plan. The B-2 General Business Zone ordinance deliberately excludes automotive service stations as a permitted use, in keeping with the Township's Master Plan goals of a pedestrian-friendly, building-oriented commercial corridor. The applicant has not demonstrated the special reasons or hardship required to override this established zoning scheme, nor has it shown the proposal meets the site's own legal requirements: the plan exceeds the 60% maximum lot coverage at 63.3%, provides only 22 of the legally required 25 parking spaces with no designated loading area, and proposes lighting that spills onto neighboring properties at nearly ten times the permitted limit.

  • Ensure traffic safety. 460 Prospect Avenue sits directly opposite the heavily congested Essex Green Shopping Center. Adding a 7-bay automotive repair facility, with its associated service traffic, vehicle storage, and customer flow, will worsen existing traffic delays and increase risks to pedestrians in the area.

  • Protect our right to a clean environment. Demolishing an existing office building to introduce heavy vehicle servicing creates unnecessary risks of chemical runoff, noise pollution, and offensive odors in a corridor that borders our residential community.

  • Defend real public benefit. This is not a new service for our town, it is a corporate relocation. West Orange gains no meaningful community benefit from setting aside its own zoning laws to accommodate a private commercial facility that could operate within its existing, legally permitted use categories elsewhere.

We do not want variances. We demand that the Zoning Board protect the integrity of our neighborhood, enforce our existing town ordinances, and safeguard our quality of life by voting NO on this application.

Sincerely,

Why is this important?

West Orange, a beautiful and thriving community in New Jersey, is facing a critical decision: whether to approve zoning variances that could fundamentally alter its character and quality of life. As residents, we cherish our town's unique blend of suburban charm and natural beauty, along with its vibrant community spirit. However, the proposed zoning variances threaten these treasured aspects of West Orange.

Zoning variances may lead to overdevelopment, increased traffic congestion, threats of severe explosion and fire hazards, environmental problems and strain on our already burdened infrastructure. Historically, similar developments in other communities have resulted in negative environmental and health impacts, such as loss of green spaces, increased pollution levels and other problems. According to a study by the Urban Land Institute, unchecked growth can lead to a decrease in property values and quality of life. We must prevent this from happening in our town.

Moreover, these zoning changes could pave the way for corporate and industrial interests to take precedence over the needs of local residents. Small businesses, which are the backbone of our local economy, may suffer as high-rise developments and big-box stores replace beloved local shops and eateries. Communities like ours thrive on character and local engagement, not on imposing developments that ignore the essence of our town.

Instead, we should prioritize smart growth strategies that respect the environment, maintain our town’s charm, and meet the real needs of all residents. This includes supporting developments that enhance our community without compromising our values. We urge our local authorities to consider sustainable alternatives that foster economic growth while preserving West Orange's unique character. And we call upon the members of the zoning board to reject these proposed variances and engage with community stakeholders in meaningful dialogue to address growth concerns in ways that benefit and respect everyone in West Orange. This is an opportunity to show that responsible and thoughtful planning can lead to long-lasting prosperity for all.

SIGN THIS PETITION TO PROTECT WEST ORANGE FROM UNNECESSARY ZONING VARIANCES AND ENSURE A SAFE, PROSPEROUS FUTURE FOR OUR COMMUNITY. LET'S WORK TOGETHER TO MAINTAIN THE VALUES AND CHARM THAT MAKES WEST ORANGE A WONDERFUL PLACE TO LIVE!